
Insider’s Guide:
Parents of high school baseball and softball athletes, if you’ve ever asked yourself:
“Why haven’t college coaches noticed my kid yet?”
“Are we spending money on the right camps or showcases?”
“What do college coaches actually look for when recruiting players?”
...then this guide was created for you.
What College Coaches Really Want (And It’s Not What You Think)

College coaches at every level are looking for very specific qualities in the kids they recruit, and knowing what matters most to coaches will help your athlete find the best college fit.
Download your free copy of The Insider’s Guide: What College Coaches Really Want
To start focusing on what actually matters in college baseball and softball recruiting.
Meet Your Coaches
We’re Carey and Garrett Crain, brothers, former college athletes, coaches, and founders of The Advantage Athletic Recruiting. We’ve worked one-on-one with athletes and families for over 10 years and have helped over 200 athletes get recruited.
Carey Crain
I began my college playing career at a junior college before transferring out to an NAIA, where I became an All-American and a College World Series competitor. Today, I run a baseball and softball academy, coach at the high school level, and mentor athletes and families through the recruiting process.
Garrett Crain
I went from being completely overlooked by college coaches in high school to playing for Texas Christian University (TCU), where I became a 2x Big 12 Champion and 2x College World Series competitor. My experience gives me unique insight into how coaches evaluate athletes and what it really takes to get recruited.
Every single day we talk with college coaches. We’ve seen what works and what holds players back. Sharing that knowledge is our way of helping more athletes find opportunities that are the best fit for them.
Inside the guide in just 3 pages, we’ll break down:
-
⚾️
The top 5 things coaches actually look forwhen they recruit
-
⚾️
The first thing every coach checks (and it’s not your batting average)
-
⚾️
What makes an athlete stand out right away (and it’s not just talent)
-
⚾️
The most common myths that keep parents wasting money on the wrong things
Why This Matters
Every family deserves a clear path to their dreams. And your kid has a better chance of getting recruited when you understand what matters most to coaches.
We've helped hundreds of families find their way from confusion to commitment. Your athlete's talent combined with the right strategy creates amazing opportunities.
Get instant access to The Insider’s Guide: What College Coaches Really Want
Your information stays private. No spam.

The Advantage Athletic Recruiting
Helping athletes get seen, get signed, and find their best-fit college home.